Question Answers Recipes Reviews Supplies Register
Cooking Baking Ingredients Equipment Techniques Entertaining Holidays Ethnic Nutrition Safety Desserts Drinks History Science Kids
What Keeps Ruining My Cookies?

Chef, I have recently graduated from pastry school and have a question about a strange flavor that I get from a cookie that I bake. The flavor is a stale or almost rancid taste. Every time! Every cookie! The cookie picks this up within a day or less. Stronger on the bottom. Once cooled, seal in a container. Ingredients: Bitter and semisweet chocolate, butter, sugar, flour, eggs, pecans. Dropped and baked on Silpat. All fresh, room temperature. The chefs at school recommended a different brand of chocolate. No change. Please advise.

Dear graduate, congratulations on your achievement!

From the list of ingredients (which must also include some baking soda or baking powder, mustn't it?, unless you're making meringues), the only possible culprit is the pecans. Nuts, because of their high oil content, are prone to going rancid. We're surprised it takes a day for the rancid flavor to develop perhaps they're already on the border and the heat of the oven sets them on an inexorable downward spiral.

We store nuts in the freezer to lengthen their shelf life, but even with that precaution, we occasionally have to throw out rancid nuts. Pecan pieces may turn rancid in as little as a month if stored above 70F (21C). In the refrigerator, they should keep for 5 months, and as long as a year in the freezer. Pecan halves, with less surface area, will generally last twice as long as pecan pieces, and nuts in the shell, twice as long as that.

We suppose there's the smallest possibility that your container is the problem, since we don't know what it's made of or what horrible smells it might be harboring. Next time you make your cookies, use nuts that you know to be fresh and taste them before adding them to the dough. Then, once cool, store at least some of your cookies in a pristine zipper-top plastic bag and the next day, they should be fine.

Now, hoping that resolves the cookie issue, let's speak about another matter. There are more and more trained chefs, and is more and more mediocre (or worse) restaurant food. We would like you to take a pledge to be a good chef no matter how clever or creative you are to only use good ingredients, to only put them together in ways that produce real flavor. We are constantly amazed and heartbroken at the number of restaurants where you cannot count on getting consistently good food. We trust the ones where you cook will consistently be good.

Submit your question
to Ochef

Related Articles:
How to Store Nuts
Chopping Nuts Evenly
Cracking Black Walnuts
What to Put in When You Take Nuts Out of a Recipe
How to Skin Hazelnuts
Related Recipes:
Moist & Nutty Brownies
Banana Nut Bread
Sausage & Chestnut Stuffing
Making Spiced Almonds
Couscous with Chicken, Almonds, and Squash

Register 2001-2006 OCHEF LLCSearchAdvertiseContact UsPrivacySite MapLinks